Skip to main content

brian@truevisiontv.com ·
Go to:   
Guardian Unlimited
Search:
Guardian Unlimited Web
Guardian UnlimitedColumnists
Home UK Business Audio World dispatch The Wrap Newsblog Talk Search
The Guardian World News guide Arts Special reports Columnists Technology Help Quiz

Lucy Mangan

 Archive

  Tools
Text-only version >
Send it to a friend
Save story >


  Search this site

 Recent articles


30 Nov 2006 
Lucy Mangan on last night's TV

28 Nov 2006 
Cable girl

28 Nov 2006 
Lucy Mangan: The footballer's wife who doesn't need feet

25 Nov 2006 
Lucy Mangan on fatherly love and portable urinals

20 Nov 2006 
Lucy Mangan on the weekend's TV

16 Nov 2006 
Lucy Mangan on last night's TV

15 Nov 2006 
Lucy Mangan on last night's TV

14 Nov 2006 
Lucy Mangan: Cable girl

14 Nov 2006 
Lucy Mangan: How do you define Englishness?

11 Nov 2006 
Lucy Mangan: Environmental crisis? I've got the perfect solution



Last night's TV



A brilliant documentary about eviction revealed the lives of the hidden homeless

Lucy Mangan
Thursday November 30, 2006
The Guardian


Evicted (BBC1) was a documentary forming part of the BBC's No Home initiative, looking at poverty and homelessness in Britain. It focused first on 13-year-old Charlotte and her family - three siblings, a mother suffering from depression and literally tearing her hair out, and a father who had had to stop work as a bus driver to look after his wife and children. They were evicted from their house by a landlord who wanted to sell the property. Then they lived in two B&Bs and a hostel. When the latter closed down they were truly roofless, and were taken in by a friend - nine people in a two-bedroom house. Charlotte did her homework on the bathroom floor and cried herself to sleep "most nights". Then the friend's housing association found out about the sharing and threatened to evict both families if they didn't leave within seven days. The greatest fear was that the children would get taken into care. Four-year-old Conor homed in, as four-year-olds will, on the practical aspects of the possibility. "What would they take us in, though?" he asked Charlotte and his big brother. "How do they get us there - do you know?" They laughed uneasily. He turned to the camera crew instead. "Do you know? Do you? Do you?"



There was a lot I didn't know. I didn't know, for example, that if one council department fails to pay a family's housing benefit on time, another department will apply to the court to have them evicted and that the court will then do so, without letting the family take nappies for the baby or a child's medication before they change the locks. I didn't know that it was the family's responsibility to try and counteract this mind-boggling lack of communication by running between god-knows-who, trying to explain the situation to everyone's satisfaction. Chloe's family didn't know that either. So they spent weeks living in a B&B after being found, in a moment of injustice striking even in a programme filled with such moments, intentionally homeless. Or, as the woman from the council put it, "The decision we are looking at is intentionality." Always a useful distancing device, jargon, when you have something devastating to say.

Still, at least the advent of Chloe and her brothers and sisters gave 14-year-old Sarah someone to play with at the B&B. She is an old hand there now. She knows that if you put a tin of beans on the radiator in the morning, they will be warm enough to eat for tea. I didn't know that, but that's maybe because I didn't know that you're not allowed to have a microwave - or any other cooking facilities - in temporary accommodation. These are Sarah's GCSE years and she would like to be at school, but it would mean four buses a day and her mum doesn't have the money.

Charlotte et al make the three-hour, 50-mile round trip every day to their school in Minehead from their emergency accommodation in Taunton, found for them by a local authority after the charity Shelter threatened to sue the authority. For the first few days, they don't know whether they will still have somewhere to stay by the time the afternoon bell goes. Meanwhile, Chloe's school won't send her any homework while she waits for a place at a new school near her temporary housing. It's the insults added so casually to injury that make you want to batter the screen.

Eventually, Chloe's family finds a private let that is willing to take DSS. Between the two parents and four grandparents they scrape together the £450 deposit required and move in. Several months later, the council admits that it should never have evicted them in the first place. This doesn't seem to be followed by any compensation or restoration of their far more affordable original house.

After two years and eight moves, Charlotte and her family are given a council house. They get their stuff out of storage and Charlotte looks forward to life without being called a tramp and a low-life by other girls at school. Sarah, seven months on, is still in temporary accommodation, has missed her GCSEs and still hasn't returned to school. It is more than likely that the cracks Sarah fell through have widened into a chasm from which she will be lucky ever to climb out.

This was a brilliant, understated film by Bafta-winning director Brian Woods, and it made you want to scream and scream and scream. Somebody should. The families themselves really don't have the energy any more.




In the know?
Sign up for our email bulletins

Related articles
28.06.2005: Tories to host homelessness summit
23.06.2005: Firms urged to take on homeless staff
14.06.2005: Cash incentive plan to ease family homelessness
21.12.2004: More than 100,000 children stuck in B&Bs
16.12.2004: Budget cuts threaten homeless hostels
14.12.2004: 500,000 homeless, claims charity
13.12.2004: Cash pledged to ease homes crisis

Web review
The most useful websites on homelessness

The Glossary
A-Z guide to public services and voluntary sector speak

Useful sites
Homelessness Act 2002
Social exclusion unit
Rough sleepers unit
Shelter
Crisis





UP


Guardian Unlimited © Guardian News and Media Limited 2006